AMA - The Boyfriend Ch. 201-210

"Is that not OK?" I asked as I texted Cattie.

'Hey, weird question. Can I borrow lube?'

"No, it's fine. I actually found it kind of sweet," Terra said softly, trailing her fingers lower to my balls and teasing them lightly. "I mean, calling me your little elf is hot, but 'honey' is a lot more normal I guess. But you don't call Cassidy that."

"I guess not," I said, running my fingers through her hair. She pressed her cheek to my shoulder as we talked and waited for a response. "I call her babe, or baby, mostly."

"You called me baby too, but I guess that's kind of a standard thing," Terra said. "What do you call the others? Do you call them honey, too?"

"Um, I don't know," I said. "I hadn't really thought about it. I guess I tell you girls you're gorgeous a lot. And I call Leia 'sunshine' because it makes her smile so much."

'Whose ass is getting fucked?' Cattie texted me back. Then,'Nvm, it's Terra. Nice! Brt.'

"Cattie's going to bring us lube," I said. "She also guessed that it's you in here with me."

"Everyone probably knows," Terra shrugged. "Whatever, I don't care. Half of them are fucking you, too. What about Wanda, do you call her anything special?"

"Um, well with her kink of the ownership stuff, I was calling her my toy," I said. "But that's pretty much done since we're cooling off so she can deal with her stuff with a clear head."

"I bet she's disappointed," Terra mumbled. "What about Becca, or Ami?"

"I don't know," I said. "Not that I've noticed, but maybe."

"You should figure out something for each of them," Terra said. "But could you do me a favour?"

"Of course," I said.

"Obviously 'little elf' doesn't apply to them, so I'm not worried about that. But could you maybe... not call any of them honey?"

"If you want," I said, feeling an odd pounding tightness in my chest as the conversation went on. "Is that what you want? To be my honey?"

"Maybe," she whispered softly. Her hand had slipped from my balls to my thigh, somehow making the moment less sexual and more just... intimate.

And the moment was broken by a sharp rapping at the door.

Terra leapt up from the bed, truly putting the moment away, and went and opened the door a bit. "Hey," she said.

"Hey, girl," Cattie said. "Here you go. How is it so far?"

"Pretty fucking amazing," Terra said, and I could hear that impish little smirk of hers in her voice. "I almost broke his cock with my ass though."

That made me laugh, and Cattie looked over Terra's head at me and grinned, seeing me openly naked with a rock-hard cock. Then she dropped back to her feet. "Well, good thing you two hit the breaks before that happened or there'd be a lot of unhappy women on these boats."

"I'll try not to go too hard on him," Terra giggled.

"Nice artwork, by the way," Cattie said. I was wondering if she'd mention it.

"Huh?" Terra asked.

"Your face is covered in his cum, babe," Cattie said.

"Oh, my God!" Terra said, shutting the door and pressing her back to it as she looked at me with wide eyes. Cattie was laughing in the corridor. "I can't believe I forgot about that. Why didn't you say anything?!?"

"How can you notfeel it?" I laughed.

"Because my ass is still distracting me, dude," Terra said, coming back over to me and hitting me with the bottle of lube in my arm.

"Well, let's fix that then," I said, grabbing her wrists and pulling her back onto the bed.

Chapter 207

"God, holy fucking Jesus, duuuuude," Terra moaned. She was on top of me again, but after about ten minutes of working her ass with my fingers and the lube, and then a quick handjob with the lube as well to make sure we were both slick, I was in.

It was still tight as fuck, and the way her asshole clamped down on me and didn't want to let go was an absolute eye-popping feeling, but she was in and she hadn't wasted any time to start riding me.

I had just started thrusting back up at her when she fell forward onto her knees with her hands braced on my chest and she let out her moan.

"That's it, honey," I groaned, reaching up and tweaking her little beady nipples. "That's it, my little elf. You're taking my cock in your ass."

"I so fucking am," Terra panted, and a little string of drool started to slip from her bottom lip before she quickly wiped it away. "I'm taking your cock sogood, right Tiger?"

"So fucking good," I grunted, stepping up my thrusts again. We were back to that ball-slapping, flesh-clapping, sweat-building fucking pace and I was in her ass. I felt like I was having an out-of-body experience.

"Fuck my fucking ass, Tiger," she growled. "Take my ass. God, you treated my ass so right and now I fuckinglove you in it. I never fucking like anal but this is everything I've been fucking dreaming of."

I raised one hand to her face and offered her my thumb like earlier and she sucked it into her mouth to muffle herself again. It wasn't that I didn't find her dirty talk super fucking attractive, but talking like that made me think of the fact that she was doing this with me and not JC.

"God damn, honey," I groaned. "Fuck I want to just rail you."

"Do it," she gasped, lewdly licking from my thumb to my palm between words. "Flip me over, spin me around. Take my ass however you want it. Just- Wait, hold on." She sat up and looked around the cabin almost deliriously for a moment, then shrugged and grabbed my phone. I unlocked it for her and she quickly brought up the photo app and contorted her body to reach behind her. She snapped a picture, then checked it, then muttered and snapped a couple more. "There," she grunted and showed me a picture of my cock buried deep in her ass, framed by her perfect little butt cheeks.

"Very hot. It can go right after the picture of your butthole you sent me," I said.

"Did you read that story I sent you?" she asked, starting to bounce on me again but slower.

"Haven't had a chance," I said. "Been a little busy."

"Do it, and think of me," she said. "You like it, right? I know it isn't as big and perfect as Wanda or Cattie-"

"God, shut up," I said, getting my foot steady and then bodily flipping us both over so that I was on top of her, my cock never leaving her ass. She quickly pulled her legs back and I was in a missionary position over her. "If you ever,ever, trying to talk down about any part of you, I'm never fucking you again."

"OK," she panted. "Never again. You love my little ass."

"I absolutely do," I grunted as I started ploughing into her again, my hands at her knees to bend her around to open her up a little more.

"And my tight little tummy," she gasped.

"Every ab," I said.

"And my tiny little tits."

"I want to suck on those nipples for hours."

"And my lips?"

"Every time I see you I want to kiss you."

"Every time I see you I want to kiss you," she said back. "And then I want to get on my knees and blow you."

"Any time you want," I groaned. "Just as long as I can eat you out whenever I want."

"That's a dangerous ask," Terra panted, fucking back at me as she pulled her own leg back, practically bending herself in half with that leg. "You almost killed me earlier. A real French moment."

"What?" I asked.

"Une petite mort," Terra gasped. "The little death."

That made me chuckle. "Right, I've heard that before."

"Well that's what you did to me," Terra said. "You gave me the best fucking orgasm I've ever had and it made me touch God."

"What about now?" I asked. "Is this doing it for you?"

"Uh-huh," she nodded loosely. "It's- fucking hell- It's different but I can feel it building."

That spurred me to redouble my efforts, and we really drilled at each other for a few minutes as our sweat splashed against each other.

"More lube," I grunted, pulling out of her slowly.

"Kay," she groaned. She'd started feeling extra tight and I wasn't sure if she was in a state of mind to realize if she was starting to get raw or not.

I quickly poured lube over my cock and stroked it. While I did that, Terra got up on her knees and arched her back, reaching back with one hand to spread her cheek and even her hole with one finger. I poured a squirt of lube directly into her asshole.

"Fuck me, Tiger," Terra moaned. "Beat my fucking ass."

I mounted her, my cock popping back into her tight as hell hole with some effort, and I could feel the difference of the new lube. It took three long strokes to get it spread around and then we were back to fucking.

"Are you close, Tiger?" Terra gasped. She was pressing her chest to the bed and had her hands clenched into fists in the sheets above her head. "Is my ass getting you there?"

"I'm so fucking close, honey," I groaned. "Fuck, the way your asshole doesn't want to let go and pulls at me like that."

"Gaaaawd, sweet Mother Mary," Terra moaned, pushing her face to the mattress to muffle herself.

"Again with the Catholic stuff," I laughed.

"Shut up and fuck me, dude," Terra grunted.

That made me smirk and I spanked her ass cheek while I was on an outstroke. Her asshole twitched at that but I was fucking her so rapidly it almost didn't register.

"When you come, I'm going to come, Tiger," Terra gasped. "I can feel it. My first anal fucking orgasm. God, fuck, do it in me. Fucking get your cum in my ass so I can feel it squirting in me and pretend you're filling my cunt."

"And the breeding fetish," I chuckled.

"I don't fucking know, dude," Terra said. "You bring it out of me."

"And I'm about to put it in you," I said, grabbing her ass cheeks roughly and slowly my thrusts but upping their forceful power.

"Do it, dude. Fucking do it. I love your fucking cock, and your lips, and your tongue. I love the way you push my fucking buttons, and the way you talk to me, and the way you fucking look at me. Fuck, I'm so fucking clooooose, Robbie. I'm so, so fucking close. I'll let you do anything you want, just fucking let me feel-"

"Uuuuuuuughh," I moaned through my clenched teeth as my cock flexed and flushed. I could feel myself get bigger just before the orgasm washed over me because of how fucking tight Terra's asshole was, and when the cum started to rocket up through it I swear I could feel it stopped by the dam that was Terra's sphincter clamped tightly. But it had the power, and it pushed through, and I erupted into Terra as a roaring sound echoed in my ears.

Chapter 208

"He's just zonked out," I heard Cassidy say. "Girl, you fucked him into a sex coma. Robbienever just falls asleep after sex."

I groaned and blinked my eyes open. "M'not asleep," I grunted. "What happened?" I was on my side and Terra was sitting crosslegged with my head in her lap, still naked, and Cassidy was up on the bed on her knees. It was almost surprising that she was still wearing clothes.

"You came so hard you passed out," Terra snickered, running her fingers through my hair. "I mean, don't get me wrong, I was coming pretty fucking hard too, but when you passed out out fell right on top of me and pinned me to the bed with your cock completely buried in my ass. You didn't even go soft. It felt amazing until I realized you were out, then I had to text Cassidy from your phone to help get you off of me 'cause of the giant dick keeping me pinned in place."

"Sorry," I said, meaning it but also chuckling a little.

"Laugh all you want, big guy," Terra said. "I feel like my asshole isn't ever going to be the same again."

"Probably not," Cassidy smirked. "It'll be dreaming of our Tiger's cock, twitching to beg you for another round."

Terra rolled her eyes and smirked. "Yeah, maybe," she said. "But if that's true, it'll be arguing with my poor little pussy. God, I feel fucked to hell and back."

"Glad you had fun, babe," Cassidy said, leaning forward and giving Terra a kiss on the cheek. "Hmm?" she hummed, raising an eyebrow, and then she licked Terra's cheek.

"Hey," Terra said, leaning away.

"You have cum on your face, babe. Smeared and dried, but definitely Robbie's cum," Cassidy said.

"Oh, God," Terra laughed. "I forgot. Again. Cattie caught me with a facial."

"She told me," Cassidy grinned. "Like I said, glad you had fun. Now, if you've got a load in your ass too, you either need to go hop in the shower or I'm going to start asking Robbie if I can have permission to lick it out of you."

"I appreciate the thought, Cass," Terra said. "But I'm still straight as an arrow. I'll take the shower." She leaned down over me to give me a soft kiss, letting it linger, then slipped out from under my head and headed into our washroom.

"Two booties down," Cassidy whispered to me as she closed in for her own kiss. "Was it as good as I think it was?"

"It was great, baby," I said, kissing her back.

"Good," she said. "You two were at it for almost an hour and a half. Did you do everything you wanted?"

"Almost," I said.

"Well, if what you want involves that sweet little straight pussy, you should go join her in the shower," Cassidy whispered. "Terra is going to want more of you, but I doubt she'll break her agreement with JC on what their lines are. Once she leaves this room, it's ass and mouth only."

"Alright," I said quietly, then hesitated. "You still OK with all of this?"

"More than OK, Tiger," Cassidy smiled gently. "Now go make love to her, 'cause I know you and I know that's what you want to do. You've fucked each other's brains out, go do the other thing."

I kissed Cassidy again, then slipped from the bed and went into the washroom. Terra was in the shower already, and when I entered behind her she smiled over her shoulder and made her bum flex a little to tease me. I stepped into the stream of water and wrapped her up in my arms, bending my neck low to kiss her.

Soon our hands were roaming and we washed each other and ourselves, and her slim fingers ended up stroking my cock as it firmed up. And then I was inside of her again, one of her legs raised high and pressed to the wall as she balanced on her toes. I was slow, savouring every moment, and we breathed together as we made out under the rain of hot water. It was different from the other kisses. It was comfortable and fulfilled. It was luxurious, like having another portion of a delicious dessert after a full meal just because it was that good.

I ended up lifting her higher, and she wrapped her legs around my waist, and I carried her out of the shower. She was a dense little package with her muscles, but still more than light enough for me to carry with ease as we dripped water across the floor and into the bedroom.

"Excuse me, babe," I grunted softly as I lowered our wet bodies to the bed and Cassidy, who was waiting for us, scooted out of the way. I laid Terra down and pulled out of her for a moment, then scooted behind her into a spooning position and got my cock back into her.

"Yessss, Robbie," Terra moaned. "God, you feel so good in me."

"Every part of me wants to make love to every part of you," I groaned into her ear.

"You already are, Tiger," she gasped. "Fuck, make love to me. Love me, dude. Love me."

I glanced down the bed toward Cassidy, who was sitting near the end of the bed and chewing on her bottom lip as she watched us with big eyes, one hand openly rubbing herself under her shorts.

I was making love to Terra, but I didn't want Cassidy to feel like she was just... watching. She had allowed this to happen, or partially set it up, or something. I appreciated that she wasn't trying to just dive in to join, especially with Terra saying she was straight. According to her stories, Cassidy hadn't exactly been discerning in the women she'd seduced using the app in the past, and I had no doubt with a few of the right words and touches she could convince Terra to try out bisexuality.

"Come here, baby," I said, motioning for Cassidy to come up and spoon behind me.

Cassidy pulled her fingers from under her shorts and slunk up the bed, pressing herself to my back as she hugged me and looked over my shoulder at Terra and I. "You two are so beautiful together," she whispered.

"One of these days I'm going to make you put on a live sex show for me," Terra moaned softly. "I may not be into girls, but after watching Robbie play with Wanda I think I'm into live porn featuring him."

I could hear the grin in Cassidy's voice even though my face was planted into Terra's hair as I kissed the back of her neck. "Any time, babe," my fiancee promised her friend. "You can have him, or watch me with him, any time."

Terra came first, soft and slow as I hugged my arm down her body and gently teased her clit through its hood with one finger. Then it was my turn, and I was getting close.

"Where?" I asked her.

"Inside me," she said, then giggled at my obvious hesitation mixed with the flexing of my cock. "I don't know."

"Terra discovered earlier that she's got a bit of a breeding fetish," I explained to Cassidy.

"That's hot," Cassidy chuckled. "Did you put a load in her?"

"No," Terra shook her head. "We were good, and I couldn't risk that with JC."

"Well, where do you want his hot, gooey, steamy, delicious load then?" Cassidy asked.

"All over me, but we just showered," Terra sighed.

"Want it in your mouth?" Cass offered.

"He's too big, I can barely fit it in," Terra said. "I don't have a big mouth like you and his little sluts."

"Like you aren't one," Cassidy teased her, patting her bare hip in a way that was somehow casual and friendly, even downright sisterly, despite the fact that the two of us were still slowly fucking. "Want me to take it, babe?"

"Probably for the best," Terra grunted.

"OK, Tiger," Cassidy said, speaking softly to me in my ear. "Get as close as you can with Terra's tight, pretty little pussy, and at the last second you pull out and roll to your back, and-"

I groaned and did just that, the first shot of my orgasm hitting Terra's hip as I got out of her just in time not to actually creampie her. Cassidy scrambled down and got my cock in her mouth, humming loudly as I erupted over her tongue and she quickly jerked the lower half of my cock with one hand.

"God, I wanted that in me," Terra chuckled to herself, reaching to her hip and scooping the string of cum up with two fingers and then popping them in her mouth to lick it off. She rolled to her other side, pressing her cheek to my shoulder and wrapping her arms around mine as she watched Cassidy suck my cum out of me. "Fuck, I love you guys."

"Love you too, Terra," I said, saying it like she'd said it; the way I told my best friends I loved them. I wasn't sure if that's all I meant though, and I wondered if that was all she meant too. And I hated myself for that.

Chapter 209

Somehow I was the one who was the most shy about leaving the cabin and venturing back out into what felt like 'the real world' compared to what had been happening in our bed that day. I'd spent time with Wanda and Becca that morning, and now Terra that afternoon. It wasn't right, or fair.

But I guess it wasn't wrong, either.

Cassidy, of course, couldn't give a fuck if anyone felt weird about it. She wasn't exactly proud of me for everything, but only because the word didn't encompass everything.

And, whether she was following Cassidy's lead or had decided it herself, Terra didn't seem to care that everyone knew what had been going on either. At the very least 'my girls' knew it all between Cass and Cattie.

My concern wasn't necessarily that everyone knew and was more focused on specific people. Front and centre in my mind was sweet and cautious Ami, who I'd shared such a soft closeness with and now I felt like this was being thrown in her face not 24 hours later. Then, right behind her was Leia - I couldn't be sure if she would take it in stride, or if she would withdraw into her more shy demeanour and not feel as comfortable with me. Which was a dumb thing to worry about considering she'd watched me with Ginnie, and then been going all out right in front of Cattie, but my worry was still there.